Re: Emacs vs pg_indent's weird indentation for function declarations

On 17/05/2019 16.48, Tom Lane wrote:
> I wrote:
>>>> A small problem with the "rejiggering" is that it now makes the wrong
>>>> choice for K&R-style function definitions, causing them to be weirdly
>>>> indented. For our purposes, that's a non-problem so I'm not excited
>>>> about trying to make it smart enough to recognize those. We do have
>>>> a couple of amazingly old and crufty K&R-style functions in src/port/,
>>>> though, so probably we'd wish to fix those.

> It doesn't really seem practical to me to make the lookahead function
> smart enough to tell the difference between attributes and K&R-style
> parameter declarations. What I'm thinking of doing to have an
> upstreamable patch is to invent a new switch, perhaps '-kr'/'-nkr',
> to indicate whether the user is more worried about K&R function
> declarations than she is about function attributes.

I think it's safe to assume that upstream can drop support for K&R-style
parameters altogether.