Re: Support logical replication of DDLs

On 2/2/26 5:04 PM, Vitaly Davydov wrote:
> 1. Log into the WAL system catalog changes (tuples) suitable for logical
> decoding (introduce a new wal_level = logical_ddl). I think, not all system
> catalog changes are needed for decoding (not sure, we have to decode
> pg_depend
> changes).
>
> 2. Implement a decoder of system catalog changes, that can produce a
> parse tree
> using existing structures from parsenodes.h.
>
> 3. Based on the decoded parse tree, we can convert it into json or DDL SQL
> statements in the output plugin. ParseTree to DDL SQL converter can be
> built-in
> into the core. Output plugin can decide which converter to use. DDL sql
> can be
> directly applied on the replica.
>
> 4. Another option is to create json/ddl-sql from system catalog changes
> without
> an intermediate representation, but, anyway, when we interpret system
> catalog
> changes we have to temporary save current data in some structures.
> Parsenodes
> is the already existing solution for it.

With this approach how do you intend to handle DDL changes which alter
data? To take a simple case we have the USING clause when altering a
column. Maybe it is a fine limitation to just not support it but I am
not convinced.

Andreas