Re: Feature Proposal: Column-Level DELETE Operation in SQL

On Mon, Apr 21, 2025 at 10:23:30PM +0530, Abhishek Hatgine wrote:
> These would act as a shortcut or expressive alias for setting one or more
> column values to NULL.

NULL values are not quite no-values, and setting some column of some row
to NULL is not quite the same as deleting the column from the row.

Even if the database's row encoding is such that a "null value" is not
written there will be bits that indicate that the column's value is
null.

Now in an entity-attribute-value (EAV) sort of schema setting a column
to NULL could be made to be the same as deleting that one row. But PG
does not currently map tables to EAV stores, though I suppose it could
eventually have table types that do just that, but that doesn't mean PG
would need a new statement type.

Even an RDBMS that only used an EAV metaschema internally would not need
a new statement type. Setting a column value to NULL is just not
"deleting a colun value".

Having two ways to do this doesn't seem necessary at all.

Moreover, with UPDATE one can set some columns to NULL values and others
to non-NULL values in the same statement, whereas one could not do that
with the new statement type you propose.

[At this point this is just piling on, for which my apologies, but I
thought the EAV thing might be worth noting.]

Nico
--