parameterized query much much slower than one with hard-coded string

From: Timbo Chen <timbo(at)powerreviews(dot)com>
To: pgsql-jdbc(at)postgresql(dot)org
Subject: parameterized query much much slower than one with hard-coded string
Date: 2011-11-10 04:44:12
Message-ID: CAOerExCvo_6n-yDR+ni-hXXADTDbEhzuqzGHinHHaWuZu_jSxw@mail.gmail.com
Views: Raw Message | Whole Thread | Download mbox | Resend email
Thread:
Lists: pgsql-jdbc

what could be the possible reason that these 2 nearly identical queries
have such different performance?
1) only difference is that one query has a named parameter replaced with a
hard-coded string
2) one without hard coded string takes about 22-30 secs to run! query with
hard coded string only takes about 22-100 millisecs.

different execution plans? how would i find out what the actual execution
plan was?

thanks,
tim

Hibernate:
SELECT r.*
FROM review_extra re, review r, product p, category_model cm,
tmp_category_ancestor tca
WHERE tca.parent_category_id = :categoryId
AND cm.category_id = tca.child_category_id
AND cm.model_id = p.model_id
AND r.product_id = p.product_id
AND re.review_id = r.review_id
AND re.key = :rotdKey
LIMIT 1

Hibernate:
SELECT r.*
FROM review_extra re, review r, product p, category_model cm,
tmp_category_ancestor tca
WHERE tca.parent_category_id = :categoryId
AND cm.category_id = tca.child_category_id
AND cm.model_id = p.model_id
AND r.product_id = p.product_id
AND re.review_id = r.review_id
AND re.key = 'review_of_the_day'
LIMIT 1

String sql = "SELECT r.*\n" +
"FROM review_extra re, review r, product p, category_model
cm, tmp_category_ancestor tca\n" +
"WHERE tca.parent_category_id = :categoryId\n" +
"AND cm.category_id = tca.child_category_id\n" +
"AND cm.model_id = p.model_id\n" +
"AND r.product_id = p.product_id\n" +
"AND re.review_id = r.review_id\n" +
// "AND re.key = :rotdKey\n" +
"AND re.key = '" + ReviewExtra.KEY_ROTD + "'\n" +
"LIMIT 1";

SQLQuery query = HibernateUtil.getSession().createSQLQuery(sql);
query.setLong("categoryId", categoryId);
// query.setString("rotdKey", ReviewExtra.KEY_ROTD);

query.addEntity(Review.class);

Review review = (Review)query.uniqueResult();
return review;

Responses

Browse pgsql-jdbc by date

  From Date Subject
Next Message Oliver Jowett 2011-11-10 05:57:41 Re: parameterized query much much slower than one with hard-coded string
Previous Message Thomas Kellerer 2011-11-05 11:12:31 Encoding for error messages during connect