Re: minor changes in psql's \encoding command

Bruce Momjian <pgman(at)candle(dot)pha(dot)pa(dot)us> writes:
> Should we throw a warning when the do it?

How? The backend can't throw such a warning (it has no way to know if
the SET is coming from the client library or a higher level). The only
way to do it would be for the client library to parse every command
passed through it to look for "SET client_encoding" ... which is
expensive and still not very bulletproof.

Perhaps in the still-mythical 7.4 protocol revision, we could consider
adding a field to backend result messages to show the current client
encoding. But I misdoubt whether it's worth adding a couple bytes to
*every* backend message to make life safe for clients who both want to
change the encoding on the fly, and want to do so behind the back of the
low-level libraries they're using. That's a cost paid by everyone to
satisfy a very small group.

I really think that documentation to the effect of "don't do it this
way, do it that other way" is the appropriate solution.

regards, tom lane