Re: tablespaces inside $PGDATA considered harmful

On 1/30/15 11:43 AM, Joshua D. Drake wrote:
> On 01/30/2015 08:19 AM, Bruce Momjian wrote:
>>
>> On Fri, Jan 30, 2015 at 11:12:43AM -0500, Robert Haas wrote:
>>> I think everyone who has read this mailing list for a while is
>>> probably already aware of this problem. When you create a tablespace
>>> somewhere inside the data directory, weird things happen. If you
>>> pg_upgrade and then incautiously run the delete_old_cluster.sh script
>>> thus created, you will blow away large chunks of your data.[1] If you
>>
>> pg_upgrade doesn't create the deletion script in this case, and warns
>> the user:
>>
>> Could not create a script to delete the old cluster's data
>> files because user-defined tablespaces exist in the old cluster
>> directory. The old cluster's contents must be deleted
>> manually.
>>
>>> In the short term, I favor just adding a warning, so that people get
>>> some clue that they are doing something that might be a bad idea. In
>>> the long term, we might want to do more. Thoughts?
>>
>> Yes, good idea.
>
> Uhm, wouldn't it be a rather simple patch to say:
>
> if tablespace_create() in $PGDATA:
> ERROR!
>
> ?
>
> I mean yes a warning is good but it is after the fact, the tablespace
> is already created. We know that tablespaces in $PGDATA are a bad
> idea, why not protect the user?

I would be in favor of an error. It would then be OK for basebackup,
pg_upgrade, and friends to error when a tablespace lives in $PGDATA,
rather than trying to deal with the situation in strange ways.

If the user really wants tablespaces in $PGDATA they can always change
the links manually in the filesystem and deal with any consequences on
their own.

--
- David Steele
david(at)pgmasters(dot)net