Re: Re: [BUGS] libpq does not manage SSL callbacks properly when other libraries are involved.

Bruce Momjian wrote:
> Russell Smith wrote:
>> Alvaro Herrera wrote:
>>> PoolSnoopy wrote:
>>>
>>>> ***PUSH***
>>>>
>>>> this bug is really some annoyance if you use automatic build environments.
>>>> I'm using phpunit to run tests and as soon as postgres is involved the php
>>>> cli environment segfaults at the end. this can be worked around by disabling
>>>> ssl but it would be great if the underlying bug got fixed.
>>>>
>>> This is PHP's bug, isn't it? Why are you complaining here
>> No, this is a problem with the callback/exit functions used by
>> PostgreSQL. We setup callback functions when we use SSL, if somebody
>> else uses SSL we can create a problem.
>>
>> I thought my original report was detailed enough to explain where the
>> problem is coming from. Excerpt from original report;
>>
>> This is part of a comment from the php bug comment history;
>>
>> *[12 Nov 2007 2:45pm UTC] sam at zoy dot org*
>>
>> Hello, I did read the sources and studied them, and I can confirm
>> that it is a matter of callback jumping to an invalid address.
>>
>> libpq's init_ssl_system() installs callbacks by calling
>> CRYPTO_set_id_callback() and CRYPTO_set_locking_callback(). This
>> function is called each time initialize_SSL() is called (for instance
>> through the PHP pg_connect() function) and does not keep a reference
>> counter, so libpq's destroy_SSL() has no way to know that it should
>> call a destroy_ssl_system() function, and there is no such function
>> anyway. So the callbacks are never removed.
>>
>> But then, upon cleanup, PHP calls zend_shutdown() which properly
>> unloads pgsql.so and therefore the unused libpq.
>>
>> Finally, the zend_shutdown procedure calls zm_shutdown_curl()
>> which in turn calls curl_global_cleanup() which leads to an
>> ERR_free_strings() call and eventually a CRYPTO_lock() call.
>> CRYPTO_lock() checks whether there are any callbacks to call,
>> finds one (the one installed by libpg), calls it, and crashes
>> because libpq was unloaded and hence the callback is no longer
>> in mapped memory.
>>
>> --
>>
>> Basically postgresql doesn't cancel the callbacks to itself when the pg
>> connection is shut down. So if the libpq library is unloaded before
>> other libraries that use SSL you get a crash as described above. PHP
>> has suggested the fix is to keep a reference counter in libpq so knows
>> when to remove the callbacks.
>>
>> This is a complicated bug, but without real evidence there is no way to
>> go to back to PHP and say it's their fault. Their analysis is
>> relatively comprehensive compared to the feedback that's been posted
>> here so far. I'm not sure how best to setup an environment to replicate
>> the bug in a way I can debug it. And even if I get to the point of
>> nailing it down, I'll just be back asking questions about how you would
>> fix it because I know very little about SSL.
>>
>> All that said, a quick poke in the source of PostgreSQL says that
>> fe-secure.c sets callbacks using CRYPTO_set_xx_callback(...). These are
>> only set in the threaded version it appears. Which is pretty much
>> default in all the installations I encounter.
>>
>> My google research indicated we need to call
>> CRYPTO_set_xx_callback(NULL) when we exit. but that's not done. One
>> idea for a fix is to add a counter to the initialize_ssl function and
>> when destory_ssl is called, decrement the counter. If it reaches 0 then
>> call CRYPT_set_xx_callback(NULL) to remove the callbacks. This is a
>> windows SSL thread that crashes iexplore and testifies to the same
>> problem http://www.mail-archive.com/openssl-users(at)openssl(dot)org/msg53869.html
>
> Sorry for the delay in addressing this bug report.
>
> Your analysis of this problem is right on target. When the SSL
> callbacks were implemented for threaded libpq, there was never any
> thought on the effect of unloading libpq while the callbacks were still
> registered.
>
> The attached patch unregisters the callback on the close of the last
> libpq connection. Fortunately we require PQfinish() even if the
> connection request failed, meaning there should be proper accounting of
> the number of open connections with the method used in this patch.
>
> We do leak some memory for every load/unload of libpq, but the leaks
> extend beyond the SSL code to the rest of libpq so I didn't attempt to
> address that in this patch (and no one has complained about it).
>
> I also could have implemented a function to unload the SSL callbacks.
> It would have to have been called before libpq was unloaded, but I
> considered it inconvenient and unlikely to be adopted by applications
> using libpq in the short-term.

I don't see why destroy_ssl_system sets up it's own mutex (that's also
called init_mutex). I think it'd make more sense to make the mutex
created in init_ssl_system() visible to the destroy function, and make
use of that one instead. You'll need to somehow interlock against these
two functions running on different threads after all.

Also, the code for destroying/unlinking appears to never be called.. The
callchain ends in pqsecure_destroy(), which is never called.

//Magnus