Re: BUG #7842: pg_dump scripts view to table

is there a way to find exactly what object/table/column creates this
circular dependency?

pg_dumb even in verbose mode does not warn/error of this situation. I
managed to find this by testing copy of production db(this should be
reported by pg_dump). also there is nothing fancy about this 'view' of mine.

in db it looks like this:
t1, t2, t3.......t10
create view1 from t1-t10

create view2 from view1 (only agregation with group by).

pg_dump creates table from view1.

best regards,
maciej lopuszanski

W dniu 31.01.2013 20:27, Tom Lane pisze:
> lopuszanski(at)oleofarm(dot)com writes:
>> 1. after using pg_dump to dump WHOLE database to file, 1 of views 'turned'
>> into a table.
>> so there is no 'create or replace VIEW XXXX .......' with definition, but
>> instead:
>> its scripted as 'create TABLE XXXX......' and definition.(in file that
>> pg_dump created)
> There's probably a CREATE RULE command further down that turns it into a
> view again.
>
>> 2. but after using pg_dump to dump only this 1 problematic 'view' (with -t
>> option) it stores it correcly as 'create or replace VIEW XXXX .......'
> That's not terribly surprising. The separate table and rule entries
> would only be used when it's necessary to work around a circular
> dependency with some other object.
>
>> it looks like pg_dump has problem with dependancies of this view.....
> I see no reason to think there's a bug here. If you still think it's
> a bug, you need to provide enough information for someone else to
> reproduce the case.
> http://www.postgresql.org/docs/9.1/static/bug-reporting.html
>
> regards, tom lane