Re: in-catalog Extension Scripts and Control parameters (templates?)

Dimitri Fontaine wrote:

> Please find attached v3 of the Extension Templates patch, with full
> pg_dump support thanks to having merged default_full_version, appended
> with some regression tests now that it's possible.

Here's a rebased version; there were some merge conflicts with master.
I also fixed some compiler warnings. I haven't reviewed the patch in
any detail yet. One thing that jump at me from the code style
perspective is the strange way it deals with "isnull" from heap_getattr.
(I think most of these should just elog(ERROR) if a null attr is found).

Another thing is that I don't find the name "uptmpl" very clear.

We might wish to see about AtlerExtensionTemplateRename -- not only the
typo in the name but also the fact that it opens/closes the catalog for
each tuple to rename -- seems suboptimal.

Keeping the "template.c" file name seems wrong -- exttemplate.c maybe?
(I renamed the parse nodes to ExtTemplate)

There was a strange bug in pg_dump; it used "qto" where I thought
qversion was appropriate. I changed it (I looked at this hunk more
closely than most others because there was a compiler warning here, but
I didn't verify that it works.)

You seem to love using Capitalized Letters for some things in error
messages; I don't find these very pretty, and anyway they violate our
style guidelines. (I think these are in elog() not ereport() calls, but
still)

--
Álvaro Herrera http://www.2ndQuadrant.com/
PostgreSQL Development, 24x7 Support, Training & Services