Re: BUG #9202: C Functions crash database too easily

rotten wrote
> While setting up a third party (commerical) provided C library functions
> I've observed PostgreSQL 9.3.2 to be very sensitive to simple typos.
>
> 1) If you create the function with a different number of arguments than
> the
> C function expects, the create works just fine. However, every time you
> do
> a select, the database chokes:

I would hope that the only typos you would be encountering in this use-case
are file-name typos which would correctly generate "file not found" errors.
Complain to the third-party that they are not making your installation easy
enough because they have not provided fully tested scripts for you to run to
setup their library - or ideally the capability to issue "CREATE EXTENSION".

As Tom said, sometimes the solutions are procedural/human in nature and not
something easily solved via technology; especially when portability is a
concern as it is in this project.

Not being a C programmer I cannot comment on how to improve usability in
these situations but the fact remains that as a developer you should be
testing these things in a controlled development environment; and as a user
you should expect it to work (and be provided tests to verify that) and also
to be able to install via file/extension name specification only.

David J.

--
View this message in context: http://postgresql.1045698.n5.nabble.com/BUG-9202-C-Functions-crash-database-too-easily-tp5791841p5791875.html
Sent from the PostgreSQL - bugs mailing list archive at Nabble.com.