Skip site navigation (1) Skip section navigation (2)

200 times slower then MSSQL??

From: "Alexander Dolgin" <alex(at)dolgin(dot)dp(dot)ua>
To: <pgsql-performance(at)postgresql(dot)org>
Subject: 200 times slower then MSSQL??
Date: 2005-01-24 18:33:39
Message-ID: E1Ct8wq-0008En-00@lata.dp.ua (view raw or flat)
Thread:
Lists: pgsql-performance
Hi all,

We are developing some application that works with DB over JDBC. We've used
MSSQL before and trying to migrate to PostgreSQL now. Unfortunately problems
with performance are found. MSSQL with default configuration looks like much
faster then PostgreSQL on the same hardware (PostgreSQL8 rc5 was used). I've
tried to increase work_mem significant (work_mem = 262144) but it doesn't
help. 
Here is result of simple benchmark. I have table 
CREATE TABLE elt_tcli_messagelog
(
  connectionname varchar(64),
  msgseqnum int4,
  connectionmessageid int4,
  logtimestamp varchar(64),
  isfromcounterparty char(1),
  msgtype varchar(64),
  possdupflag char(1),
  isoutofsequence char(1),
  ordtrnid varchar(64),
  ordrqstid varchar(64),
  counterrequestid varchar(64),
  clordid varchar(64),
  origclordid varchar(64),
  execid varchar(64),
  exectranstype varchar(64),
  exectype varchar(64),
  ordstatus varchar(64),
  lastqty float8,
  orderqty float8,
  cumqty float8,
  leavesqty float8,
  sendercompid varchar(64),
  targetcompid varchar(64),
  tradeaccthrchy varchar(64),
  tradeacctid varchar(64),
  routedtransactiondestination varchar(64),
  originatingconnectionname varchar(64),
  originatingconnectionmsgid int4,
  instrument varchar(64),
  portfolio varchar(64),
  prevseqnum int4,
  "Message" text,
  nonmetadatafields text
)

with about 8000 rows. For this table query:

SELECT MAX(MsgSeqNum),MAX(LogTimestamp) FROM ELT_tcli_MessageLog 
WHERE LogTimestamp  >=  '0' AND IsFromCounterParty  =  'Y' AND
IsOutOfSequence = 'N' 
     AND ConnectionName  =  'DB_BENCHMARK' 
     AND LogTimestamp IN (SELECT MAX(LogTimestamp) 
                          FROM ELT_tcli_MessageLog 
                          WHERE MsgSeqNum  >  0 AND IsFromCounterParty = 'Y'

                                AND IsOutOfSequence  =  'N' AND
ConnectionName  =  'DB_BENCHMARK')

takes about 1 second on MSSQL Server and 257 seconds on PostgreSQL one.

Does anybody have idea about reasons of such results?

Thanks,
Alexander Dolgin.


Responses

pgsql-performance by date

Next:From: Litao WuDate: 2005-01-24 23:02:42
Subject: reltuples after vacuum and analyze
Previous:From: Ragnar HafstaĆ°Date: 2005-01-24 18:24:05
Subject: Re: PgPool changes WAS: PostgreSQL clustering VS MySQL

Privacy Policy | About PostgreSQL
Copyright © 1996-2014 The PostgreSQL Global Development Group