Re: BUG #5438: Bug/quirk in ascii() function

"Christoph Zwerschke" <cito(at)online(dot)de> wrote:

> ascii(cast(' ' as char(1))),
> ascii(cast(' ' as char))
> both give 0.
>
> I think this quirk should be fixed or at least mentioned in the
> documentation of ascii().

The problem is not in ascii(), but in casting from char to text.
We have only one version of ascii() in default; ascii(text).
So, if you use ascii( ' '::char(1) ), it is actually handled as
ascii( ' '::char(1)::text ). Traling spaces were removed during
the cast to text. You could have the same result with other databases
if you define a char version of ascii().

=# CREATE FUNCTION ascii(bpchar) RETURNS integer AS 'ascii' LANGUAGE internal;
=# SELECT ascii(cast(' ' as char(1)));
ascii
-------
32
(1 row)

Do you know how the SQL standard mention the behavior? IMHO, postgres'
behavior is more reasonable because length(' '::char(1)) is 0.

Regards,
---
Takahiro Itagaki
NTT Open Source Software Center